Cataldos Pizza on Robert Lane Serves up fresh New York Style hand tossed pizza. We are also known for our giant slices, pasta dishes, and fresh deli sandwiches. Cataldo’s is family owned and operated with two locations to serve you. Unlike most of our competitors we do not use dough sheeters or presses. Nor do we use conveyor belt ovens. At Cataldo’s we prefer to do things. Each of our pizzas are hand-tossed and baked in brick ovens. Every pizza must be rotated during the cooking process. Therefore, you will experience a wait during our busy hours.